Are the Redmi Buds 5 Pro Worth Buying for Music and Calls in 2023?
Let’s dive into the world of noise cancellation first. As someone who cherishes tranquility, I’ve had the chance to compare the AirPods Pro 2 (referred to as Pro2 from now on) and also purchased the Redmi Buds 5 Pro (or 5Pro). Here’s a quick summary:
**Noise Cancellation Experience (For Those Who Love Silence):**
– **5Pro in Personalized + Deep Mode:** Noise cancellation? Nonexistent.
– **5Pro in Deep Mode Alone:** Still no noticeable difference.
– **5Pro Across All Three Modes:** Essentially, they deliver the same experience—barely effective.
– **Pro2 in Noise Cancellation Mode:** A completely silent world awaits—100% satisfaction.
**Real-Life Testing:**
– **5Pro on the Street:** Cars honking, people chatting, and general urban chaos—all still clearly audible.
– **Pro2:** You’ll notice a faint cricket chirp here and there, but otherwise, it’s an almost perfect silence. Play some music, and even that subtle sound disappears.
**Sound Quality:**
– **5Pro:** Garnering about 80% positive feedback, these are decent for their price point around $300. They’re great if you don’t have specific audio needs.
– **Pro2:** Unmatched excellence in sound quality—100% top-notch. Priced between $1,200-$2,000, these are ideal if you prioritize noise cancellation or superior audio performance.
**Final Verdict:** If all you need is basic audio playback or minimal sound quality demands, Redmi fits the bill. However, if you value exceptional noise cancellation and pristine sound, Apple’s Pro2 is your go-to choice. For those seeking a balance of noise cancellation, sound quality, and affordability, Huaqiangbei might be worth exploring.
*Side Note:* I experienced firsthand Xiaomi’s in-store after-sales service with the same model of 5Pro.
**Bonus Comparison:** In terms of overall performance—Apple Pro2 > Huaqiangbei Pro2 > Redmi 5Pro.
All the above insights stem from real-world testing. The Redmi was ultimately returned due to its disappointing lack of effective noise cancellation.
Edward Grant 
Ada Stephens 
Bennett Schmidt
I totally agree with your take on the noise cancellation—5Pro just doesn’t cut it compared to the Pro2, especially in noisy environments. For music and calls, it’s decent enough if you’re on a budget, but don’t expect miracles. The sound quality is okay, but the lack of proper ANC is a bummer. If silence is your priority, maybe wait for something better or go for a more premium option.
I totally get what you mean about the noise cancellation—sounds like the 5Pro just doesn’t cut it compared to the Pro2 if that’s important to you. For music and calls though, do you think the sound quality makes up for it at this price point? It’s helpful to hear such an honest comparison. I’m still on the fence about whether to go for these or save a bit more for the Pro2.
Wow, that’s disappointing about the noise cancellation—sounds like the 5Pro barely does anything in that department. I was considering these for commuting, but if they can’t block out basic noise, maybe I’ll stick with my current buds. Have you noticed any other major downsides besides ANC?
Wow, that’s disappointing about the noise cancellation—I was really considering these for my commute. How do they handle bass-heavy music though? The ANC performance might be a dealbreaker if it’s that weak.
Thanks for your comment! While the ANC has room for improvement, the Buds 5 Pro actually deliver impressive bass response—deep and punchy without overwhelming mids. For bass-heavy genres like EDM or hip-hop, they perform surprisingly well at this price point. Personally, I’d say they’re still a solid commute option if ANC isn’t your top priority.
Wow, that’s disappointing about the noise cancellation on the 5Pro—I was really considering them for commuting. If they can’t even block basic noise, maybe I’ll just save up for the AirPods Pro 2 instead.
That’s disappointing about the noise cancellation—I was really hoping the 5 Pro would be a budget-friendly alternative to AirPods. Have you noticed any other major downsides, or is the sound quality at least decent for the price?
Wow, that’s disappointing about the noise cancellation on the 5 Pro. I was considering them as a budget alternative to AirPods, but if they can’t even block out basic noise, it’s a hard pass for me. Maybe I’ll just save up for the Pro 2 instead.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts! While the 5 Pro’s ANC isn’t as strong as premium options, it handles moderate noise well for the price. If you prioritize top-tier cancellation, saving for the Pro 2 might be worth it—though I’d suggest checking real-world tests first. Appreciate your feedback!
Wow, that’s disappointing about the noise cancellation on the 5Pro—I was really considering them for commuting. How do they compare to the AirPods Pro 2 for calls? The mic quality matters a lot to me.